Dec 11, 2024
When Tourism Has Gone Too Far
- By
Hélène Huret
When Tourism Has Gone Too Far
Dec 11, 2024
by
Hélène Huret
When Tourism Has Gone Too Far
Dec 11, 2024
by
Hélène Huret
When Tourism Has Gone Too Far
Dec 11, 2024
- By
Hélène Huret
When Tourism Has Gone Too Far
Dec 11, 2024
- By
Hélène Huret
sustainability
When Tourism Has Gone Too Far
Dec 11, 2024
- By
Hélène Huret
Frank Hoeft
M

orir por exito, to die of success, is a Spanish expression that is becoming increasingly popular on Mallorca. In 2023, 12.5 million tourists visited the island, which has nearly one million residents. In 50 years, the number of tourists has multiplied by twenty, and the number of residents by three. With the exception of the Covid, these figures have never stopped rising since the 1950s. For years, this increase was a source of pride. For a long time, the majority of the population and the public authorities did not look down on tourism because it is the industry that sustains Mallorca. Criticism did exist, but it was quietly expressed with a fatalism summed up by the phrase: es lo que hay or, ‘it is what it is.’ 

But this year it seems as if tourism has reached a point of no return. Despite Covid, when a temporary slow down allowed residents to briefly reclaim their beaches and mountains, air traffic and tourism have resumed their mad rush. In 2023, with more than 31 million passengers, the Palma airport broke its attendance record. A record that is difficult to digest. This race to the top, based on ever-increasing numbers, is no longer acceptable to the public. This summer, protests were big and many, reaching international news and attention.  Residents took to the streets in the middle of summer to say stop. We saw them in Palma and on the beaches with signs reading Ocupem les nostres platges ‘Let’s occupy our beaches.’ It was a peaceful way of showing tourists how fed up they are.

Since 2019, Fundament, a non-profit association with a mission of helping people find solutions to real problems and live better together through design, has been seeking to understand how Mallorcans experience tourism in order to improve coexistence in an increasingly polarised world. “This year,” explains Frank Hoeft, designer and co-founder of Fundament, “we've seen a significant increase in unhappiness across the population [of Mallorca].” 86% of people surveyed said they would live better if there were less tourism. 81% felt that tourism did not respect or value local culture and that it disrupted their daily lives.  96% of respondents deplore the impact of tourism on the environment. Over the last twenty years, the human pressure indicator has increased by almost 40%. Yet the island's natural limits are easy to reach and its ecosystems, such as the coastline and mountains, are fragile. This over-visitation is leading to saturation of infrastructures and public spaces, greater pollution and pressure on resources, which on certain days transforms a paradise island into a nightmare.

“W

hat's striking,” says Hoeft, “is that this criticism also affects those who work in tourism: 81% of Mallorcans working in tourism say that sometimes they would live better without tourism. This figure is 37% higher than in the survey carried out in 2022!  In our studies,’ he explains, “we ask people whether they are directly or indirectly connected to tourism. In 2022 there was a difference in feeling between people working in the tourism sector and those who didn't. Today, more and more people are answering the same question.” 

Hoeft continues: “This feeling of frustration comes from the accumulation of many problems”. Traffic, for example. “Apart from the number of rental cars, the lifestyle of the residents has also changed – it's not unusual for a family to have two cars." And the cars are getting bigger. Put these big cars on a small mountain road and you get traffic jams. Carried along by increasingly warm winters, the season never ends. It seems that successive governments' aim of reducing the seasonality of tourism is on the way to being achieved, making traffic complicated even outside the summer months. Not only Soller, but also the roads leading to Palma often suffer in April and October. Property and housing is another sensitive issue: 72% of people surveyed by Fundament have difficulty finding accommodation because of seasonal rentals.  Young people just starting out in their careers are paying the price. Some may be forced to leave the island. It's a desperate situation similar to that of Venice, a city completely deserted by locals. There is 1 resident for every 96 tourists in Venice, compared with 1 resident to every 13.3 tourists in Mallorca.

Finally, social networking means that there are no longer any secret coves or beaches - now tourists are everywhere. Although only accessible after a long walk, Cala des Moros has become one of the most famous coves in the world. At the height of the season, almost 4,000  people want to discover this dream beach: from June to September, people queue up to have their photo taken and go down onto the beach.  This density leads to an estimated 50 kg of sand being lost every day, inevitably reducing the size of the beaches and creating a feeling of overcrowding.This is as true on Mallorca as anywhere else. In 2015 Justin Bieber filmed a video clip in the grandiose Fjadrargljufur canyon in southern Iceland. Within a few months, the place was overrun with visitors, seemingly happy to take a photo without showing the slightest interest in nature. As a result, the canyon has been closed to the public since 2017. With social networks, a photo can reach millions of people around the world in just a few clicks. The massification of tourism is correlated with the massification of images.

For 97% of those questioned, tourism is driving up prices, particularly for leisure activities. Mallorca is one of the most expensive regions in Spain to live in. If Mallorca does not want to morir por exito, its model must evolve. The majority of people questioned by Fundament stressed the need for tourism to focus on quality rather than quantity. A paradigm shift that inspires hope. 60% of those questioned believe that by 2030 tourism will have declined and will be regulated. Better still, 56% think that tourism will be sustainable, respectful and will protect the environment. But 96% would prefer to have a diversified economy that does not depend solely on tourism. A strong message addressed in particular to the government and the tourism industry.

Participate in the 2024 survey and share your experience about tourism.

@fundament.asociacion

Related Stories.
Sep 25, 2024
Esment Foundation